Anonymous user
Evolving Raichu: Difference between revisions
m
[Dummy edit to add a summary for the previous edit] Paraphrased, and added links to the text templates in the disassembly. (I fumbled and hit the Enter key.)
No edit summary |
m ([Dummy edit to add a summary for the previous edit] Paraphrased, and added links to the text templates in the disassembly. (I fumbled and hit the Enter key.)) |
||
Line 5:
This NPC can be found in Cinnabar Island's Pokémon Laboratory, and requests a Raichu in exchange for Electrode.
== Procedure ==
#Walk to this man in Cinnabar Island's Lab. that wants to trade a Raichu for an Electrode. Select Yes and initiate the trade.
#After that, speak to him again, and he will tell you the Raichu evolved.
Line 11:
[[Image:raichu1.png]][[Image:raichu2.png]] [[Image:raichu3.png]]
== Why it happens ==
This error happened in localization: English {{RB}} took its in-game trade data from Japanese {{RG}}, but the text templates<ref>[https://github.com/pret/pokered/blob/6c945a6b6a0d21ba4bf0c2977bb44d2482dffcb8/data/text/text_7.asm#L140 This specific text template] corresponds to <code>TRADE_DIALOGSET_POLITE</code> in [https://github.com/pret/pokered/blob/6c945a6b6a0d21ba4bf0c2977bb44d2482dffcb8/data/events/trades.asm this table].</ref> of in-game trade NPCs were translated from {{JB}}. In Japanese Red and Green, none of the Pokémon the player can trade to an NPC would evolve by trading, and thus this text template says something unrelated to evolution. On the other hand, in Japanese Blue, for the two in-game trades using this text template, the player needs to trade in a Kadabra (for this one) and a Haunter (for the other one) respectively, both of which would evolve by trading, so the NPC claiming that they "went and evolved" is appropriate (and may serve as a hint at the game mechanic).<ref>[http://www.math.miami.edu/~jam/azure/forum/buzz/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=1;t=000207 Who's that <nowiki>[Traded]</nowiki> Pokémon?] by Meowth346, the Azure Heights forum</ref>
Incidentally, for the other in-game trade using this text template, the player trades in a Poliwhirl for a Jynx, and the NPC will similarly claim that the Poliwhirl "went and evolved". Since the intention of this line in Japanese Blue is likely to hint at the game mechanic, this can also be considered an error<ref>[https://www.moviemistakes.com/game6856/factual Pokemon: Red and Blue factual errors]</ref>, albeit a more ambiguous one since Poliwhirl can evolve to Poliwrath (when exposed to a Water Stone).
== Trivia ==
*According to Yomiuri Shimbun, Raichu was once in fact originally intended to evolve into a Pokémon known as "Gorochu" with fangs and two horns. It was apparently removed from the game due to balance concerns ([http://www.siliconera.com/2018/05/03/pikachu-originally-second-evolution-called-gorochu-large-fangs-two-horns/ source]).
| |||